Which coloration should I go with?

I'm currently working on drawing my 3 starters and I'd like to draw all my fakemon in this low-pixel style.

I've finished the fire and grass starter, but I can't decide on which color pattern to use! It's called Soggin, the idea is that it's a sort of dog-like salamander with a wooly pelt that it soaks with water and then runs around on land, watering plants and making puddles.

The large, single-colored area will look perfectly fine once I get to shading it, so I wouldn't worry about that specifically. I just can't decide between the two!

Also, if you have any ideas for alternate color choices, then feel free to say so! I just need the coat to be blue so that it looks soaked (I may also add a puddle beneath it once I render).

Thank you!